3 Smoked Porter Extract Recipes I Brewed and Ranked

Smoked Porter reviews

I first tried a smoked porter recipe from Label Peelers in 2024. It was dark brown in color, a rich, full-bodied ale. All the recipes discussed were for extract brewing.

I found that a smoked porter tastes better the longer it is conditioned in the bottle. After 4 weeks, the aroma and taste were more complex. After 8 weeks, it was a smooth, dark ale with the cherrywood smoke aroma and flavor coming to the front.

Cherrywood smoked malt imparts a complex, pleasant aroma and flavor with a balanced and subtle hop finish.

This has become an annual winter favorite, even with friends who are not fans of darker beers. I typically brew it in mid-October, bottling it around the start of November, then let them marinate until January.

My Top Three Smoked Porter Recipes

Since that first experiment, I have tried 3 different Smoked Porter recipes.

  1. LabelPeelers – Cozy Campfire Porter Kit – A smooth, full-bodied ale with complex tasting and aroma notes with the cheerywood smoked malt at the forefront.
  2. AI Smoked Porter: More of a dark chocolate taste and aroma than the other two recipes. The Chinook hops provide a bit more bitterness, with the Willamette accentuating the woody aroma.
  3. Brewer’s Best may be third, but it is good. I would consider buying it again.

The key to buying Brewer’s Best recipe kits is to make sure you buy from a seller who moves a decent amount of recipes. You don’t want to receive a recipe kit that has been sitting on a shelf for months.

I buy the Brewer’s Best Smoked Porter recipe kit on Amazon. Just make sure the seller has decent sales over the past 30 days.

smoked porter in winter

My favorite Smoked Porter extract recipe comes from LabelPeelers.

The most recent recipe was generated from our AI Beer Recipe Generator.  You can check out the recipe here.

I just bottled this latest smoked porter recipe a few weeks ago and will let it age for about 6 more weeks (if I can resist it for that long!). I had to taste one recently. My excuse was to check on carbonation. I also mark the caps on the last 4 bottles and use them as an excuse to try any recipe within about 7 to 10 days. I have discovered the last 2 to 4 bottles can have a bit more sediment from the bottom of the bottling bucket, so I reserve them for tasting. That’s at least my excuse.

The three recipes are similar for ingredients, yet have enough differences to make sure each has its own unique characteristics. The recipes are listed below, along with my tasting notes.

I will update this as my latest recipe has had more bottle conditioning time, but my favorite so far is the recipe kit from Label Peelers. Don’t get me wrong, Brewer’s Best is a decent and cheap alternative. I just get concerned about the freshness of the ingredients.

Smoked Porter Recipe Costs

Label Peelers Smoked Porter Recipe Kit:  $44.99

  • Cost does not include shipping

Brewer’s Best Smoked Porter Recipe Kit: $46.74

  • Cost from Amazon includes shipping. Their kits come with yeast, bottle caps, and priming sugar.

Smoked Porter from our AI Beer Recipe Generator: $36.44 + $6 shipping

Recipe Ingredients from the 3 Smoked Porter Recipes

Smoked porter recipes

Label Peelers Smoked Porter Recipe Kit Ingredients – Cozy Campfire Porter

Specialty Grains:

  • 1 lb Cherry Wood Smoked Malt
  • 1 lb Caramel Munich 60L Malt
  • 8 oz Chocolate Malt
  • 4 oz Black Malt

Fermentables: 6 lbs Pilsen DME

Hops

  • 1 oz Chinook
  • 1 oz East Kent Goldings

Yeast:  SafAle S-04

Original Gravity: 1.062  Final Gravity: 1.014  ABV: 6.5%  IBUs: 33   SRM: 29

Tasting Notes: A dark brown beer with smoky campfire character from the Cherry Wood Smoked Malt, caramel sweetness from the Caramel Munich 60L Malt, and layers of chocolate and roast from the Chocolate Malt and Black Malt. The cherrywood smoked malt imparts a gentle, sweet, and slightly savory smoke profile. A tan head that laces down the glass. The aroma, especially after 4 weeks of conditioning, is a complex pleasure. The cherrywood smoked malt is dominant with a savory aroma, but also offers faint hints of dark chocolate, caramel, and roasted coffee.

Smoked Porter from our AI Beer Recipe Generator

Ingredients were bought on RiteBrew.com, one of our top-rated online beer supply stores.

Specialty Grains

  • 12 oz Cherrywood Smoked Malt
  • 8 oz Chocolate Malt
  • 8 oz Caramel/Crystal 80L

Fermentables

  • 6 lbs LME
  • 1 lb Dark DME

Hops

  • 1.5 oz East Kent Goldings
  • 1 oz Willamette

Yeast: SafAle US-04

Tasting Notes: A rich, full-bodied dark brown ale with subtle cherrywood smoke notes and a velvety mouthfeel. The balance of roasted malts and dark crystal provides a complex profile that finishes smooth and slightly sweet. The aroma is complex, with the cherrywood smoked malt at the forefront. There are subtle hints of dark chocolate and caramel.

Brewer’s Best Smoked Porter Recipe Kit Ingredients

Specialty Grains:

  • 1 lb Smoked Malt
  • 8 oz Chocolate Malt
  • 8 oz Cara Brown
  • 4 oz Biscuit Malt
  • 2 oz Coffee Malt

Fermentables

6 pounds Amber LME

Hops

  • 1 oz Columbus
  • 1 oz UK Fuggle

Yeast:  SafAle S-04

The kit also includes 5 oz dextrose for priming, 60 bottle caps, muslin grain bag

Original Gravity: 1.062  Final Gravity: 1.016  ABV: 6.0%  IBUs: 32   SRM: 29

Tasting Notes: Dark brown color, full-bodied ale. It is not as smooth as the other two smoked porter recipes. There is a subtle taste from the biscuit, chocolate, and coffee steeping grains. The minimal head is tan and does not last. The aroma is complex, with the smoked malt being the primary scent on the nose. There are also subtle hints of dark chocolate and coffee.

If you haven’t tried a smoked porter recipe, you should brew one in winter. It is easy to brew, offers a unique flavor and aroma profile that should please all palates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *